Rethinking Intelligence: The Role of Beliefs in Education Equity

Posted in SSZ Briefings  ·  18th November 2021

Carol S. Dweck, a renowned psychology professor at Stanford University, has long advocated for a shift in how intelligence and learning are perceived in educational settings. Her research underscores not just the necessity for equitable resources in schools but also the critical impact of educators’ beliefs on student achievement.

The Power of Mindset

Dweck’s investigations reveal two primary beliefs about intelligence that profoundly affect educational outcomes. A fixed mindset views intelligence as a static trait; some students are deemed inherently smart, while others are not. Conversely, a growth mindset sees intelligence as something that can be developed through effort and effective teaching.

Fixed Mindset vs. Growth Mindset in Education

In her 2010 article “Mind-Sets and Equitable Education,” Dweck discusses the stark differences in student progress when taught under these differing mindsets. Educators with a fixed mindset often see low achievers remain stagnant, while those with a growth mindset witness significant improvements in their students, with many moving from low to high achievers over an academic year.

The Importance of Effort Over Innate Ability

While acknowledging that not everyone can be an Einstein, Dweck emphasises that even Einstein himself had to engage in relentless effort to achieve his breakthroughs. This viewpoint challenges the educational focus on innate ability and highlights the importance of effort and perseverance. Students with a growth mindset, she notes, not only achieve higher but also enjoy their educational journey more than those with a fixed mindset.

Addressing Stereotypes and Encouraging Potential

Dweck’s research also sheds light on the particular benefits of a growth mindset for students from stereotyped groups, such as ethnic minorities and girls in STEM fields. By prioritising effort and resilience over perceived natural intelligence, educators can help dismantle harmful stereotypes and encourage all students to reach their potential.

Cultivating Growth Mindset Cultures

For true change, Dweck argues that both educators and students need to embrace the belief that intelligence is not fixed but can be developed. This shift can create a culture of growth in schools, where teachers feel empowered to learn and improve, thereby better supporting their students’ growth.

Conclusion

As we reflect on the impact of our own educational experiences and the messages we pass on, it becomes clear that fostering a growth mindset could be the key to unlocking student potential across diverse backgrounds. By changing our beliefs about intelligence, we can help create a more equitable and effective educational system.

Questions for Reflection

  • What kind of education mindset did you receive from your teachers?
  • Which mindset is your school promoting?
  • Which mindset are you passing on to your students?

Carol Dweck’s work continues to inspire educators and students alike, offering a foundation for developing resilient learners who are equipped to face the challenges of the future.

Hashtags for Sharing

#GrowthMindset #EducationalEquity #CarolDweck #MindsetShift #StudentPotential #LearningBeliefs #EducationReform #TeacherDevelopment #ResilientLearners #EquitableEducation

This blog aims to stimulate discussion and reflection among educators and students on the profound impact beliefs about intelligence can have on educational practices and outcomes.


Back to blog home